AM Best Ratings Explained: Insurer Financial Strength

am best ratings

When you buy car insurance, you are buying a promise: that the company will pay your claim, even if it is a big one, even years from now, even after a catastrophic hurricane season. AM Best ratings are the industry’s standard measure of whether an insurer can keep that promise. Understanding what these ratings mean — and how to use them when choosing a car insurance company — is a small effort that protects you from a rare but devastating risk: your insurer being unable to pay.

What Is AM Best?

AM Best is a credit rating agency focused exclusively on the insurance industry. Founded in 1899, it has been evaluating insurers’ financial strength for well over a century, making it the oldest and most insurance-specialized of the major rating agencies. While other agencies rate insurers too, AM Best’s ratings are the most widely referenced benchmark in the insurance world — regulators, agents, and informed shoppers all watch them.

Am best ratings at a Glance

AM Best ratings explained: what insurer financial strength grades mean, why they matter for your car insurance, and how to check them. Below, we break down am best ratings in detail so you can act with confidence.

Table of Contents

Importantly, AM Best ratings measure financial strength and ability to pay claims — not customer service, not price competitiveness, not claims satisfaction. A company can have a top financial rating and mediocre customer reviews, or vice versa. Use AM Best for what it is: a solvency check.

The AM Best Rating Scale

AM Best assigns Financial Strength Ratings on a scale from A++ down to D, grouped into tiers:

Secure Ratings (Strong Ability to Pay)

  • A++ and A+ (Superior): the highest ratings — exceptional ability to meet ongoing insurance obligations
  • A and A- (Excellent): very strong financial position with minimal vulnerability to economic stress

Vulnerable Ratings (Weaker Positions)

  • B++ and B+ (Good): sound finances but more susceptible to adverse economic conditions
  • B and B- (Fair): adequate currently, but vulnerable to unfavorable changes
  • C++ and C+ (Marginal): weak financial position, significant vulnerability
  • C and C- (Weak): very weak, with serious concerns about ongoing viability
  • D (Poor): under regulatory supervision, in liquidation, or of serious concern

Ratings may also carry modifiers and outlooks (positive, stable, negative) indicating the direction AM Best expects the rating to move.

What About “Not Rated”?

Some insurers — particularly very small or new companies — are not rated by AM Best, often because they have not sought a rating (the process involves fees and extensive disclosure). “Not rated” is not automatically a red flag, but it means you lack independent verification of financial strength. With unrated insurers, lean harder on your state regulator’s data and consider sticking with rated companies for full confidence.

Why Financial Strength Matters for Car Insurance

For most drivers, insurer insolvency feels like a distant, theoretical risk — and usually it is. State guaranty associations provide a backstop, paying covered claims (up to state limits) if a licensed insurer fails. But that backstop has limits and complications:

  • Guaranty caps may not fully cover large claims
  • The process is slow — claims can sit in limbo during receivership
  • Unearned premium refunds may be partial

A strong AM Best rating means you are unlikely to ever need the backstop. When comparing an unfamiliar regional insurer against a national giant, the rating is what lets you evaluate the smaller company’s stability objectively instead of guessing.

How AM Best Determines Ratings

AM Best analysts evaluate insurers across several dimensions:

  • Balance sheet strength: capital reserves, asset quality, and leverage — can the company absorb major losses?
  • Operating performance: underwriting profitability and earnings consistency over time
  • Business profile: market position, diversification, and competitive advantages
  • Enterprise risk management: how well the company identifies and manages risks, including catastrophe exposure and reinsurance

Ratings are reviewed regularly and can be upgraded or downgraded as conditions change — which is why checking the current rating matters more than remembering an old one.

How to Check an Insurer’s AM Best Rating

1. AM Best’s website offers a rating search — the authoritative source

2. The insurer’s own website — reputable companies prominently display their ratings

3. Your agent or broker can provide current ratings for any carrier they quote

4. State insurance department websites sometimes link rating information

Check the rating at purchase time and glance at it again every few years. Downgrades are worth noticing: a company sliding from A to B+ deserves a second look before your next renewal.

What Rating Should You Require?

There is no single rule, but practical guidance:

  • A++ to A-: the comfort zone — the vast majority of reputable auto insurers sit here
  • B++ to B+: acceptable for many shoppers, especially with a strong state regulatory record and good complaint data — common among smaller regional insurers
  • B and below: proceed with caution; make sure the price discount genuinely compensates for the added risk, and verify everything else about the company
  • Unrated: fine for small premiums with eyes open, but prefer rated insurers for significant coverage

Remember: the rating is one input, not the whole decision. Pair it with complaint ratios, claims satisfaction data, price, and coverage fit.

Frequently Asked Questions

What do AM Best ratings measure?

They measure an insurer’s financial strength — its ability to pay claims and meet ongoing obligations. They do not rate customer service, pricing, or claims handling quality.

What is a good AM Best rating for car insurance?

A++ through A- (Superior to Excellent) represents the strongest tier and covers most well-established auto insurers. B++ to B+ (Good) is generally acceptable, particularly for smaller regional companies with clean regulatory records.

Is AM Best the only rating agency for insurers?

No — other major agencies also rate insurers’ financial strength. AM Best is simply the most insurance-specialized and widely cited. Checking a second agency’s rating for confirmation never hurts.

Can AM Best ratings change?

Yes. Ratings are reviewed periodically and can be upgraded or downgraded based on the insurer’s financial condition, operating results, or risk profile. Always check the current rating rather than relying on memory.

What happens if my insurer goes out of business?

Your state’s guaranty association typically covers outstanding claims up to statutory limits, but the process can be slow and caps may leave large claims partially unpaid. This is exactly why choosing a financially strong insurer upfront matters.

The Bottom Line

AM Best ratings answer one critical question: can this company pay what it promises? For most major insurers the answer is a reassuring yes — but when a tempting quote comes from a company you have never heard of, the rating is your reality check. Make it a habit: whenever you compare car insurance quotes, spend two minutes checking each finalist’s financial strength rating alongside its price and complaint record. The cheapest premium in the world is no deal if the company behind it cannot pay your claim.

Rules and rates change, so double-check the details of am best ratings with the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. For more ways to save, keep reading the guides linked below.